nerdnyc.com
 > SAVE THE DATE: RECESS JUNE 29th!    > RECESS: Submit Games!  

 > True Nerd Trivia: May 29th    > Boardgame Night: June 21st  

 WHAT'S NEW?   RULES   FACEBOOK   TWITTER   CALENDAR   PLAYER SEARCH   PRIVATE ROOM   STEAM   NEW TO NYC?   NERDNYC SHIRTS 


Is that Dominion?

Love in a little plastic bag with cardboard backing + grind-core, math-rock, polka, musical parody,

Postby mumblethrax on Wed Jan 25, 2012 3:14 pm


Yes, I said one trillion times better! First of all, unlike xkcd or me, Dinosaur Comics is self-aware, and (generally) does observational humor well. Second, it's not intended to provide snapshots, as Saif said--there's no hint of realism here. This isn't a situation webcomic, like xkcd or Full House or Precious Moments figurines. Third, it often provides insights, and not just information. It's the difference between taking a class with your favorite professor and reading a textbook (or, I dunno, an online encyclopedia). Fourth, it's all about the journey. The pleasure is in getting there with Dinosaur Comics, the punchline is usually in the second panel, not the final one, and it's seldom the point in any case. In xkcd, the journey is a tedious exercise all about setting up the (more often than not) lame joke. SF-1, table P1. Ha ha, good stuff.

xkcd is like talking to your friend who probably has asperger's, and he starts droning on about the pinouts on his favorite processor package, and you're like, man, I wish I had some way of not talking to you/reading this.
"From what I've observed some birds are pretty gay." ~ Evilyn
User avatar
mumblethrax
Grand Master of Flowers
Location: Up in this

Postby cawshis on Wed Jan 25, 2012 3:19 pm


And yet, I can't help thinking:
Image
While reading mumbles posts here. :)
"Destroying role-playing games should be a priority of every role-playing gamer"- James
User avatar
cawshis
Six Lifepath Character
Location: South Harlem, NY

Postby mumblethrax on Wed Jan 25, 2012 3:20 pm


cawshis wrote:And yet, I can't help thinking:
Image
While reading mumbles posts here. :)

Not at all, not at all! There is no accounting for taste!

Which is a blessing for those of you who would be made paupers! :x :x :x
"From what I've observed some birds are pretty gay." ~ Evilyn
User avatar
mumblethrax
Grand Master of Flowers
Location: Up in this

Postby mumblethrax on Wed Jan 25, 2012 3:34 pm


Another interesting fact here is that there is a joke here which might be worth making, namely that Randall Munroe stand-in character is implying (without self-awareness) that not only does he suck, but that he's sucked for much longer than stand-in for all women character thinks he has. Drawing our attention to that fact might have opened up the possibility for a joke that didn't just paint the glasses-pusher as a smug tool that we're supposed to relate with.

It's just that he couldn't find his ass with two hands, so we just have clumsy say-don't-show dialog leading us to the guy being satisfied that he's corrected her.

HATE.
"From what I've observed some birds are pretty gay." ~ Evilyn
User avatar
mumblethrax
Grand Master of Flowers
Location: Up in this

Postby gronti on Wed Jan 25, 2012 4:47 pm


I think Mumbles just doesn't get it.
"Finally the jokes here are getting funny." - smelly goblin
User avatar
gronti
Bigfoot Hunter
Location: Rego Park

Postby mumblethrax on Wed Jan 25, 2012 4:48 pm


I DON'T GET IT? YOU DON'T GET IT. THIS WHOLE COURT'S DON'T GET IT.
"From what I've observed some birds are pretty gay." ~ Evilyn
User avatar
mumblethrax
Grand Master of Flowers
Location: Up in this

Postby dorje on Wed Jan 25, 2012 6:03 pm


mumblethrax wrote:xkcd is like talking to your friend who probably has asperger's, and he starts droning on about the pinouts on his favorite processor package, and you're like, man, I wish I had some way of not talking to you/reading this.


I don't agree with you that this applies to xkcd, but I certainly can relate. :bing:
User avatar
dorje
Syntheholic Anonymous
Location: Astoria, Queens

Postby mumblethrax on Wed Jan 25, 2012 6:39 pm


hey thats mean you guys are mean :(
"From what I've observed some birds are pretty gay." ~ Evilyn
User avatar
mumblethrax
Grand Master of Flowers
Location: Up in this

Postby Saif on Wed Jan 25, 2012 8:01 pm


Mumblethrax > :hug1: < Saif
Flojin: Saif says, "And you're racist!" SAIF WINS!
User avatar
Saif
Nerd of Prey
Location: Kew Gardens

Postby mumblethrax on Wed Jan 25, 2012 8:41 pm


mank you por da hugz

*sniffoows*
"From what I've observed some birds are pretty gay." ~ Evilyn
User avatar
mumblethrax
Grand Master of Flowers
Location: Up in this

PreviousNext

Return to Books, Comics, Music, Art

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest